FDA Tells 23andMe to Stop Marketing: Death Knell for DTC Genomics 1.0?

The FDA on Friday published a letter  addressed to 23andMe’s CEO, Anne Wojcicki, telling the company to cease marketing it’s Saliva Collection Kit and Personal Genome Service (PGS). In the letter, Alberto Gutierrez, Director of the Office of In vitro Diagnostics and Radiological Health, describes the many interactions the Agency has had with 23andMe, informing the Company of the need to comply with the regulations and attempting to assist the Company in doing so. He also describes how 23andMe did not fulfill their promises to provide information to the Agency. I’m kind of surprised that 23andMe did not work with the FDA, since it ought to be no surprise that the FDA would order 23andMe to stop, given their apparent lack of compliance. Hopefully we will find out more about why the Company thought they could ignore the FDA.


Two additional thoughts that this development seems to support: the final bell for DTC genomics 1.0 and FDA is going to regulate genetic tests. 23andMe was really the last prominent player in DTC genomics left standing, after Navigenics and deCode were purchased by big Life Sciences firms with no apparent interest in consumer genomics. It sort of confirms that the space of unregulated genetic testing with medical information packaged alongside is rapidly diminishing in size and probably won’t exist in this form for long. It seems likely that these technologies and products will end up being regulated and available largely via prescription. Score one for the medical profession. However, there may well be a next chapter written and it could have some interesting twists. Say, for example, a 23andMe equivalent offers that service from an international location. I think it will ultimately be hard to hold a lid on consumer genetic testing.

This entry was posted in DTC Genetic Testing, genomics, personalized medicine, Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.